The Desire to Know: Are We Searching for the Truth, or for What We Want to See?

A Psychoanalytic Deep Dive into “You Can See Everything” - We Don't Just Want the Truth. We Want to Believe in Something.

Watching You Can See Everything left me with an overwhelming sense of shock. It felt almost as if I had been strapped to a chair for three hours and forced into an intense, nonstop brainstorming session.

As I walked out of the theatre, chatting with my friend about our impressions, I could hear people around us animatedly debating the same questions: Was Liz truly "innocent," or was she a master manipulator? Who was really manipulating whom?

Amid all these discussions, a thought suddenly occurred to me: Does the truth about Theranos really matter? Are we, the audience, actually the ones being manipulated?

Objectivity and Subjectivity

Cinematically, the film initially appears to unfold through Nathan's perspective as a documentarian. The camera seems to objectively record events, leaving us with one enormous question: Could Liz really have been misunderstood by the entire world? After all, how could someone who doesn't even know how to use the word "can" have built the Theranos empire?

As the film progresses, however, the cinematic language gradually takes on more of Nathan's personal style. He employs a strategy he previously used in rehearsals, bringing in Amanda to help reconstruct scenes that he was unable to record. On the surface, this seems to be an attempt to recreate the "truth" for the audience. But something more subtle is happening here. The film plants a small, almost hidden hook.

There is a particular moment that reveals this. While Amanda is delivering her lines, she repeats something Liz originally said. Nathan interrupts her: "That's not how she said it. Say it again."

In the second half of the film, what appears to be a reconstruction of actual events gradually reveals itself to be something else: we are, in fact, entering Nathan's story, a subjective account of events.

The same sentence, delivered with a different tone or intonation, can produce an entirely different perspective and interpretation.

This idea is echoed in the excited discussions that take place after the film ends.

The film reminds me of Tom Riddle's diary in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Just like the people who interact with the diary, Nathan, and we as the audience, gradually get drawn into a narrative without even realizing it. We become entangled in our own subjective interpretations of reality, while the original objective truth begins to feel less important.

Reality and Fantasy

I think one of the film's greatest achievements is its subtle, almost uncanny exploration of a deeply dialectical question: What is the relationship between reality and fantasy?

What is real? When someone's fantasy becomes dominant and begins to infiltrate their reality, could that fantasy itself become another kind of truth?

Another storyline in the film follows the relationship between Liz and Billy. From the outside, it is not difficult to suspect that Billy may be an obsessive and abusive partner. Yet, in Liz and Billy's eyes, what they share is the ultimate form of true love.

From the perspective of law, which operates within a framework of objective facts, fantasy has little room to exist. If you defraud people, you have committed fraud and may go to prison. Sincerely believing that you have done nothing wrong does not exempt you from the consequences.

But when it comes to love, the boundary between fantasy and reality begins to blur, depending on the people experiencing it.

When Amanda, like us, begins to wonder whether these two people are completely delusional, and who exactly is manipulating whom, Nathan responds with something unexpected:

"But their love is real."

Perhaps we could call this a psychological truth.

It is a form of love that grows out of a person's own fantasy. Yet, for the person experiencing it, that love is entirely real.

And how many of us have experienced our own versions of psychological truth?

Think about someone you have fallen for. You notice their many appealing qualities: their height, beauty, wealth, kindness, or the way they take care of others. Gradually, almost unconsciously, you fall in love with them. You become convinced that the person you have fallen in love with is who they truly are.

But how much of that person are we actually seeing, and how much are we seeing through the fantasy we have constructed around them?

I think the final conversation between Amanda and Nathan is the most brilliant part of the entire film.

Amanda asks him whether his desire to protect Liz had caused him to overlook something important.

Nathan doesn't answer.

And how could Nathan, or any of us, really answer that question? How do I know whether what I perceive as reality is actually reality, or a fantasy into which I have infused my own emotions, desires, and personal meanings?

Ambiguity Is What Ignites Desire

Perhaps it is precisely the ambiguity surrounding the truth, the sense of something being neither entirely true nor entirely false, that ignites our desire.

It creates a desire to investigate, to discuss, to question, and to know more.

But where does this desire come from? Is it rooted in our own insistence on uncovering an objective truth? And does the version of the truth I choose to believe ultimately reflect my own fantasies?

Perhaps what makes the film so compelling is not that it gives us answers, but that it leaves just enough uncertainty for us to keep searching.

One final thought:

Nathan may be the greatest manipulator of them all. He manipulated our desire to know the truth, and somehow made us willing participants in our own manipulation.